Sweat & detox Blood, urine and sweat comparison · 2017

Flame retardants appeared in sweat, but not urine

Five PBDE flame retardants were detected in sweat samples. The study did not measure whether repeated sauna lowered the amount stored in the body.

Worth knowing: This is the BUS sample also used for BPA, phthalates and PCB/PFAS papers; do not count it as an independent replication.

The short version

This BUS analysis looked for five PBDE flame retardants in blood, urine and sweat. None was detected in urine. Across 17 usable sweat samples, 84 of 85 compound tests were positive. That is a striking detection finding, but it is not 85 people or a measured reduction in body stores. The study did not follow a sauna treatment course or assess whether removing these chemicals improved health.

Keep in mind

The 85 sweat tests are five chemicals measured in 17 people, not 85 independent participants.

What they found

PBDEs appeared in 84 of 85 sweat compound tests and none of the urine samples. Some were detectable in sweat despite a negative blood result.

What this means for your practice

The finding is a reason to test repeated sweating properly, not proof of a detox benefit.

Methods and limitations

What the researchers did

Twenty adults supplied samples. Three lacked enough sweat for this analysis.

How much can this tell us?

Blood results were reported per gram of blood lipid; sweat was tested as collected. Those concentrations are not a direct measure of relative total clearance.

What makes it useful

  • Measures five specific chemicals

What limits it

  • No treatment follow-up
  • Small shared sample
  • Different fluid measurement bases
Where this study fits

Where this study fits

We score claims, not single studies. This one is part of the evidence for:

From the same participant group as 3 other articles in The Study, so we count them as one group of people.

Read the original

Genuis SK et al. Human Excretion of Polybrominated Diphenyl Ether Flame Retardants: Blood, Urine, and Sweat Study. BioMed Research International. 2017.

Read the original study

DOI 10.1155/2017/3676089 · PubMed 28373979

Next reading

  • 20 participants

    Sweat & detox Blood, urine and sweat comparison · 2012

    BPA appeared in sweat, including when blood tests missed it

    A small study detected BPA in sweat from 16 of 20 adults. It did not track whether repeated sweating lowered the amount in their bodies.

    Same cohort as this article

  • 17 matched comparisons

    Sweat & detox Blood, urine and sweat comparison · 2012

    Plastic-related chemicals were found in sweat

    Phthalates and some breakdown products appeared in sweat. Their concentrations differed from urine, without measuring total removal from the body.

    Same cohort as this article

All articles in The Study